Dana Crum - Poet and Writer
  • News
  • Bio
  • Publications
  • Events
  • Videos
  • For Hire
    • Writing Coach
    • Tutoring
    • Editing
  • Blog
  • Contact

On Being Accused of Praising Eliot’s Poetry and Ignoring His Bigotry

6/29/2013

1 Comment

 
Picture
During an online discussion on linkedin, someone castigated me for praising Eliot’s talents as a poet and ignoring his racist views. Here’s what I wrote in response:

You’re right to bring up what I will call "Eliot’s possible bigotry." I don’t always mention them, but I’m always aware of Eliot’s failings. Eliot was an extreme anti-Semite, according to Anthony Julius and others, though critic Denis Donoghue disputes the charge or tries to lessen it. If I refused to read a writer from the past (or present) for being racist, sexist, jingoistic (e.g., Kipling) or for being in some other way majorly flawed, there would be very few writers left to read. As a person of color, I have, my entire life, been reading writers whose craft I respect but whose political, social and personal views nauseate me. I’m not excusing these writers for their racism, sexism, etc. Not at all. What I advocate is seeing these writers’ merits as creators of literature and their flaws as individuals. Certainly, the two sides (creator and individual) can’t be completely separated. Maybe they can’t be separated at all. And I, for one, don’t try to. This is what Cornel West was getting at when he used the phrase “ambiguous legacies.” Writers, philosophers, intellectuals, etc., from the past have good things to offer present and future generations. But many of them also have much in them that’s regrettable, even despicable. Rather than seeing just one side of such writers, etc., I strive to see both sides. The good and the bad. Sometimes I might discuss one and not the other, but I assure you the other is in my mind. Sometimes I don’t bring up the other, but if I don’t, it’s because it’s a given. It’s an understood, if unspoken, fact. But it’s a given, an understood, unspoken fact for me, but not for every reader. So you’re on to something. I should bring up Eliot’s flaws while praising his merits lest others get the mistaken idea that I’m not aware of his plentiful flaws. I assure you: I don’t downplay his anti-Semitism (if indeed he was an anti-Semite) just because I admire his line breaks, musicality and striking imagery. I will never let racist/sexist/homophobic writers off the hook for their hateful beliefs and actions. To be completely honest, what I think of such writers is similar to what I think of America. This country has come a long way since the time of slavery, lynchings and marginalized status for people of color and women, and yet America is still full of racism, sexism, homophobia and other hateful thinking, behavior and policies. A major aspect of my existence has to do with seeing the good and bad in America, the good and bad in American writers, and really the good and bad in the world and its writers. And for that matter, the good and bad in me.

1 Comment
Loiter Squad link
8/27/2023 02:29:46 am

Veryy creative post

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Dana's Blog

    Thanks for stopping by. I'm glad you could make it.

     

    RSS Feed

     

    Categories

    All
    9/11
    Adam Gopnik
    Agnosticism
    Alabama
    Alumni Matters
    Anti-Semitism
    Blank Verse
    Business World
    Childhood
    Christianity
    College
    D.C.
    Difficult Poets
    Digital Media
    Editing
    Egyptian Protests
    Ekphrasis
    Existentialism
    Fragmentary Writing
    Friendship
    Good Friday 2000
    Hip-hop
    Human Trafficking
    Humor
    Jk Rowling
    John Keats
    Justice
    Langston Hughes
    Life Of The Writer
    Linguistics
    M.I.A.
    M.L.K.
    My Published Fiction
    My Published Nonfiction
    Natasha Trethewey
    Outkast
    Poetry
    Princeton
    Professional Development
    Publishing Industry
    Racism
    Republicans
    Shakespeare
    T.S. Eliot
    Tutoring
    Unions & Black Labor
    U.S. Politics
    Violence
    Visual Art
    W.B. Yeats
    W.E.B. Du Bois
    Whorfianism
    Winslow Homer
    World Politics
    Writing
    W.S. Merwin


    Archives

    May 2016
    March 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2012
    February 2012
    September 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010

     

    Favorite Blogs

    Prose Wizard
    Bino A. Realuyo
    Fatback and Foie Gras
    Guy's Library